| 53 Old Mill Lane, Thurgoland, Sheffield, S35 7EG | Apr 2025 | £415,000 | Detached | Freehold |
| Wantacyu Old Mill Lane, Thurgoland, Sheffield, S35 7EG | Feb 2025 | £310,000 | Semi-detached | Freehold |
| Birch Croft Old Mill Lane, Thurgoland, Sheffield, S35 7EG | Feb 2025 | £430,000 | Detached | Freehold |
| Stonecroft Old Mill Lane, Thurgoland, Sheffield, S35 7EG | Oct 2024 | £850,000 | Detached | Freehold |
| 1, Old Mill Cottages Old Mill Lane, Thurgoland, Sheffield, S35 7EG | Oct 2023 | £475,000 | Semi-detached | Freehold |
| Oaklands, 49 Old Mill Lane, Thurgoland, Sheffield, S35 7EG | Jun 2023 | £630,000 | Detached | Freehold |
| Don House Old Mill Lane, Thurgoland, Sheffield, S35 7EG | May 2023 | £750,000 | Detached | Freehold |
| Ranworth Old Mill Lane, Thurgoland, Sheffield, S35 7EG | Jul 2022 | £350,000 | Other property | Freehold |
| Inglenook Old Mill Lane, Thurgoland, Sheffield, S35 7EG | Feb 2022 | £270,000 | Semi-detached | Freehold |
| Glen Garry Old Mill Lane, Thurgoland, Sheffield, S35 7EG | Feb 2022 | £250,000 | Semi-detached | Freehold |
| Tree View Old Mill Lane, Thurgoland, Sheffield, S35 7EG | Jun 2021 | £500,000 | Detached | Freehold |
| 2, Old Mill Cottages Old Mill Lane, Thurgoland, Sheffield, S35 7EG | May 2021 | £368,500 | Other property | Freehold |
| Rivelin Old Mill Lane, Thurgoland, Sheffield, S35 7EG | May 2021 | £340,000 | Semi-detached | Freehold |
| 45 Old Mill Lane, Thurgoland, Sheffield, S35 7EG | Jan 2021 | £415,000 | Detached | Freehold |
| Fiddler Farm Old Mill Lane, Thurgoland, Sheffield, S35 7EG | Nov 2018 | £675,000 | Other property | Freehold |
| 43 Old Mill Lane, Thurgoland, Sheffield, S35 7EG | Mar 2018 | £450,000 | Detached | Freehold |
| Waterfall Cottage Old Mill Lane, Thurgoland, Sheffield, S35 7EG | Jul 2017 | £550,000 | Other property | Freehold |
| Furnace Cottage Old Mill Lane, Thurgoland, Sheffield, S35 7EG | Jul 2017 | £270,000 | Terraced | Freehold |
| The Old Wire Mill Old Mill Lane, Thurgoland, Sheffield, S35 7EG | Feb 2010 | £600,000 | Detached | Freehold |
| Cherry Cote Hall Old Mill Lane, Thurgoland, Sheffield, S35 7EG | Mar 2009 | £246,000 | Detached | Freehold |
| Rivermill Barn Old Mill Lane, Thurgoland, Sheffield, S35 7EG | Mar 2006 | £319,950 | Detached | Freehold |
| Woodmoor Old Mill Lane, Thurgoland, Sheffield, S35 7EG | Sep 2003 | £132,000 | Semi-detached | Freehold |
| Tilt Mill House Old Mill Lane, Thurgoland, Sheffield, S35 7EG | Feb 2003 | £210,000 | Detached | Freehold |
| Dorlyn Old Mill Lane, Thurgoland, Sheffield, S35 7EG | Nov 2002 | £95,000 | Semi-detached | Freehold |
| Jephcote Old Mill Lane, Thurgoland, Sheffield, S35 7EG | Jan 2001 | £110,000 | Detached | Freehold |
| The Homestead Old Mill Lane, Thurgoland, Sheffield, S35 7EG | Jan 1997 | £60,000 | Terraced | Freehold |
| Crossland House Old Mill Lane, Thurgoland, Sheffield, S35 7EG | Jan 1997 | £80,000 | Semi-detached | Freehold |
| The Old Mill Old Mill Lane, Thurgoland, Sheffield, S35 7EG | Apr 1996 | £270,000 | Detached | Freehold |