| Old Post Office Shrewsbury Road, Penistone, Sheffield, S36 6DY | Jan 2025 | £340,000 | Other property | Freehold |
| 2, The Old Vicarage Shrewsbury Road, Penistone, Sheffield, S36 6DY | Dec 2024 | £500,000 | Semi-detached | Freehold |
| 9 Shrewsbury Road, Penistone, Sheffield, S36 6DY | Apr 2024 | £153,000 | Terraced | Freehold |
| 11 Shrewsbury Road, Penistone, Sheffield, S36 6DY | Nov 2016 | £86,000 | Terraced | Freehold |
| 4, The Old Vicarage Shrewsbury Road, Penistone, Sheffield, S36 6DY | Aug 2014 | £499,950 | Detached | Freehold |
| 3, The Old Vicarage Shrewsbury Road, Penistone, Sheffield, S36 6DY | Apr 2014 | £490,000 | Detached | Freehold |
| 1, The Old Vicarage Shrewsbury Road, Penistone, Sheffield, S36 6DY | Sep 2012 | £335,000 | Semi-detached | Freehold |
| Flat 2, 23 Shrewsbury Road, Penistone, Sheffield, S36 6DY | Aug 2009 | £110,000 | Flat / maisonette | Leasehold |
| Flat 3, 23 Shrewsbury Road, Penistone, Sheffield, S36 6DY | Aug 2009 | £110,000 | Detached | Leasehold |
| St. Johns Vicarage Shrewsbury Road, Penistone, Sheffield, S36 6DY | Feb 2006 | £285,000 | Detached | Freehold |
| 15 Shrewsbury Road, Penistone, Sheffield, S36 6DY | Jun 2002 | £49,950 | Terraced | Freehold |
| 13 Shrewsbury Road, Penistone, Sheffield, S36 6DY | Oct 2000 | £37,500 | Terraced | Freehold |
| 40 Shrewsbury Road, Penistone, Sheffield, S36 6DY | Jul 1999 | £152,000 | Detached | Freehold |