| The Coach House, The Old Vicarage, Penally, Tenby, SA70 7PN | Feb 2026 | £193,500 | Flat / maisonette | Leasehold |
| 2 Bay View, The Old Vicarage, Penally, Tenby, SA70 7PN | Jun 2021 | £287,500 | Flat / maisonette | Leasehold |
| Seaview, The Old Vicarage, Penally, Tenby, SA70 7PN | Oct 2020 | £190,000 | Flat / maisonette | Leasehold |
| First Floor Apartment, The Old Vicarage, Penally, Tenby, SA70 7PN | Jun 2020 | £275,000 | Flat / maisonette | Leasehold |
| Bronllwyn, Penally, Tenby, SA70 7PN | Oct 2019 | £410,000 | Detached | Freehold |
| Woodlands, Penally, Tenby, SA70 7PN | Jul 2019 | £300,000 | Detached | Freehold |
| Brackenlea, Penally, Tenby, SA70 7PN | Nov 2018 | £320,000 | Detached | Freehold |
| Hillside, Penally, Tenby, SA70 7PN | Mar 2016 | £256,000 | Detached | Freehold |
| Kilara, Penally, Tenby, SA70 7PN | Jan 2013 | £398,000 | Detached | Freehold |
| The Ground Floor Apartment, The Old Vicarage, Penally, Tenby, SA70 7PN | Sep 2010 | £250,000 | Flat / maisonette | Leasehold |
| Mews 1, The Old Vicarage, Penally, Tenby, SA70 7PN | Sep 2010 | £175,000 | Flat / maisonette | Leasehold |
| Bay View 1, The Old Vicarage, Penally, Tenby, SA70 7PN | Jul 2009 | £200,000 | Flat / maisonette | Leasehold |
| Garden Cottage, The Old Vicarage, Penally, Tenby, SA70 7PN | Aug 2008 | £158,000 | Detached | Leasehold |
| Mews 2, The Old Vicarage, Penally, Tenby, SA70 7PN | Jun 2008 | £190,000 | Flat / maisonette | Leasehold |
| The Old Vicarage, Penally, Tenby, SA70 7PN | Nov 2004 | £865,000 | Detached | Freehold |